How to be a better fundraiser | Kara Logan

Fundraising is essential for nonprofit organizations, with individual donations making up 64% of funding ($319 billion). Here's how to improve your fundraising efforts:

• Understand Donor Motivation: Build emotional connections - 75% of donors give when they feel connected to a cause.
• Address Challenges: Combat donor fatigue, diversify income sources, and focus on recurring donations.
• Build Trust: Share transparent updates, send personalized thank-you messages, and show clear impacts of contributions.
• Leverage Technology: Use tools like HelpYouSponsor for donor management and optimize online donation systems.
• Create Engaging Campaigns: Use personalized messages, success stories, and measurable goals to inspire donors.
• Retain Donors: Thank donors promptly, involve them in your mission, and show how their money is used.

Start by collecting donor data, setting up a thank-you system, and offering recurring giving options to create lasting relationships with supporters.

Top 5 Tips for Building Strong Donor Relationships

What Makes Donors Give

Understanding donor psychology is crucial for effective fundraising. Research indicates that 75% of donors need to feel emotionally connected to a cause before giving, while 61% base their decisions on personal experiences. Let’s examine the main factors that drive donations.

Donor Motivation Factors

In child sponsorship programs, several motivators influence donor behavior:

Mrs. Anne Humes, who has been sponsoring children for over 60 years, beautifully describes the emotional connection:

"I'm glad to be able to help the little children. They're a wonder. They keep me awake and very much alive."

These motivators highlight the importance of creating a meaningful connection with donors.

Building Donor Trust

Beyond motivation, trust is the cornerstone of long-term donor relationships. As Karen Cochran from Philanthropy Innovators puts it:

"You earn trust in drops but lose it in buckets."

Here are effective ways to establish and maintain donor trust:

• Transparent Communication: Share monthly updates, visuals, and real-life case studies.
• Personal Recognition: Send timely thank-you notes, personalized messages, and celebrate donor milestones.
• Impact Reporting: Demonstrate the value of contributions with detailed reports, success stories, and clear fund allocation.

Taryn Palumbo of Orange County Grantmakers adds:

"Donors are much more likely to trust a nonprofit if they have established a relationship before they ask for a donation."

Creating Strong Fundraising Campaigns

Effective fundraising campaigns require careful planning. For example, 39% of donors are more likely to give after hearing a testimonial, and consistent communication can triple donation amounts.

Custom Donor Messages

Strong donor communication starts with segmentation and personalization. By centralizing donor data, you can tailor messages to resonate with different groups. Here's a quick breakdown of how to approach messaging:

The Save a Puppy Foundation provides a great example of personalized messaging. For new donors, they send tailored welcome notes like this:

"Dear Edward, Welcome to the Save a Puppy Foundation family! Thank you for your generous contribution of $100 to the vaccination drive. Your gift will help the puppies in community shelters to receive their necessary vaccinations in order to get adopted. If you have further questions or want to get more involved with this campaign, please visit our website at saveapuppyfoundation.com or follow us on Instagram to meet the puppies you've helped save today."

Using Success Stories

Sharing success stories helps build emotional connections, which can significantly boost donations. Organizations using compelling storytelling see a 45% donor retention rate, compared to just 27% for those that don't. Here's how to make your stories impactful:

• Focus on individuals: Highlight specific beneficiaries instead of relying on general statistics.
• Incorporate visuals: Use high-quality photos or videos to show the direct impact of donations.
• Simplify your language: Avoid complicated terms or jargon.
• End with a call to action: Make it clear how donors can continue to help.

"When someone decides to donate to your organization, two crucial elements must come together - their understanding of the problem and a belief that they can make a difference."

By combining personalized messages, emotional stories, and clear goals, you can create a fundraising campaign that resonates with your audience.

Campaign Goals and Tracking

Setting measurable goals is key. Campaigns that update supporters every five days raise three times more donations.

• Define Clear Metrics
  • Set targets for total donations, new donors, average gift size, and donor retention rates.
• Use Visual Progress Updates
  • Tools like fundraising meters can keep donors engaged and motivated.

    "Goals are more likely to be achieved if donors can clearly see the fundraising progress and they can easily visualize their impact."

• Monitor and Adjust
  • Track daily donations, donor segment performance, message effectiveness, and social media engagement.

These strategies ensure your campaign stays on track and continues to inspire donors.

Digital Tools for Better Fundraising

Digital tools simplify tasks and help nonprofits connect better with donors. In fact, 96% of nonprofits say technology has played a role in their growth. These tools not only make operations smoother but also build stronger donor relationships. Here's a look at some key tools that can elevate fundraising efforts.

HelpYouSponsor: Managing Donors and Sponsorships

HelpYouSponsor (HYS) is designed to help nonprofits handle sponsorships and engage with donors more effectively. Here's what it offers:

Plans are flexible, with options starting at $0.50 per commitment, making it scalable for different needs.

Making Decisions with Donor Data

Analyzing donor data can lead to better fundraising outcomes. For example, 83% of nonprofits say integrated systems save them about 7 hours per week. Here are some ways to make the most of donor data:

• Track Key Metrics: Monitor donation frequency, average contribution size, and retention rates.
• Segment Donors: Group donors based on their giving patterns, interests, or engagement levels.
• Use Predictive Analytics: Identify trends and potential major donors through advanced forecasting tools.

Better Online Donation Systems

A user-friendly online donation system can complement data-driven strategies and improve donor experiences. Key features to consider include:

Keeping Donors Long-Term

Strengthening relationships with donors is key to improving retention. For instance, second-time donors are 60% more likely to keep giving compared to first-time donors. Below are strategies to help you thank, engage, and inform donors to encourage ongoing support.

Donor Thank-You Program

Expressing gratitude promptly and thoughtfully can make a huge difference. Donors are four times more likely to give again if they’re thanked within 48 hours. Tailor your approach based on the donor type:

• First-time donors: Send a personalized thank-you within 48 hours.
• Recurring donors: Use a mix of email and follow-up calls to show appreciation.
• Major donors: Opt for personal touches like phone calls or handwritten notes.

Organizations that combine multiple channels for thank-yous see a 15% higher retention rate compared to those that rely on just one. The secret? Personalize your message by mentioning the donor's specific gift and its impact.

Ways to Involve Donors

Since 88% of nonprofit funding often comes from the top 12% of donors, it’s crucial to keep them engaged. Consider offering opportunities like:

• Exclusive events
• Volunteer programs
• Invitations to advisory committees
• Feedback sessions

These initiatives deepen their connection to your mission and encourage long-term involvement.

Showing Donation Results

Let donors see the real-world results of their contributions. Around 80% of donors say they want to know how their money is being used. Plus, 60% of donors are willing to give up to 10% more when they see clear outcomes. For example:

Share these results through monthly updates, visuals, beneficiary stories, or even live dashboards. This transparency builds trust and motivates donors to continue their support.

Conclusion

Main Points Review

Successful fundraising combines smart use of data, meaningful relationships, effective tech tools, and thoughtful donor care:

• Data-Driven Decisions: Monitor metrics like donor retention and average donation size to guide your approach.
• Personal Connection: Build trust through regular communication and clear reporting on how donations make an impact.
• Technology Integration: Automate repetitive tasks while maintaining a personal touch.
• Donor Stewardship: Show appreciation and keep donors engaged with consistent follow-ups after their contributions.

These principles can transform your fundraising efforts when turned into actionable steps.

Getting Started

Here’s how to begin:

1. Start with Data Collection
   Set up a simple database to track key metrics like average gift size and response rates. Consistently monitoring this data can help refine your strategies.
2. Set Up a Thank-You System
   Implement an automated system to send a thank-you message within 48 hours of receiving a donation. Follow up with personalized updates to show the impact of their contribution. Studies show donors are more likely to give again when they see how their money is being used effectively.
3. Launch a Recurring Giving Program
   Add a recurring donation option to your forms. Recurring donors typically contribute 42% more annually. Here’s an example of how you could structure this:

   Giving Level	Monthly Amount	Annual Impact
   Supporter	$25	Feeds 300 children
   Champion	$50	Supports 2 classrooms
   Guardian	$100	Funds entire programs

Related Blog Posts

• 7 Proven Donor Management Strategies That Increase Long-Term Retention
• Nonprofit Fundraising Ideas in 2025
• How I Would Learn Nonprofit Fundraising (If I Could Start Over)